Wednesday, April 02, 2025

Labour: Indian media’s blind spot

 Written By Invitation in The Migration Story

Link: https://www.themigrationstory.com/post/labour-indian-media-s-blind-spot


Five years ago, India came to standstill.  Not because it wanted to but because it was told that it had to. That this was the only way to check the spread of a deadly virus that was already raging around the world.


The national lockdown announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on March 24, 2020, at 8 pm on television, did little to assuage the growing anxiety about the spread of the Corona virus.  Instead, it will be remembered for forcing our poorest, most vulnerable and hard-working citizens to flee our cities and make their weary way back to their homes thousands of kilometres away from their places of work.  


The four hours’ notice for a national lockdown led to a panic, especially amongst the urban poor. For them a lockdown meant not safety but the loss of jobs as all work stopped. So, they picked up their belonging and left the city -- by train, truck, bus, or even on foot.


The images representing this exodus from our cities five years ago, of an estimated 10 million people, ought to have woken us up to the reality of informality, of the existence of the virtually invisible men and women who build, and service our cities. But did it? 


To what extent has mainstream media been responsible for moving the focus away from this reality once the millions forced to leave their jobs and their homes stopped moving? Do we know how many survived, how many came back, did they find work again, have they recovered from the financial loss they must have incurred?


I would suggest that the main reason mainstream media in India covered the “great exodus” from our cities is because it was a spectacle that could not be ignored.  And it was taking place within easy reach of where media houses are located, in the metro cities, in state capitals.  It was one of the rare occasions where the poor and working class made it to the front pages of newspapers and on television screens.  


If, as in the past, mainstream media houses had continued the tradition of having a “labour” beat, we would have known the answer to these questions. 


A part of reporting on labour was news about trade unions.  Today, many of them have downsized or virtually disappeared. Even if they exist, media rarely gives space for their views. This has contributed to the invisibility of working-class problems including those that face the informal sector. 


Also, covering “labour” included reports on closures of factories, strikes by workers like the textile strike in Mumbai, unsafe work conditions, and the precarity faced by the growing sector of informal and unorganised workers.  Today, such stories are rare although the ground reality remains the same.


Looking back at those two years, 2020 post the lockdown, and 2021 when a new, and more virulent strain of the virus hit the country, a study of what grabbed media attention and what was ignored tells us a great deal about the state of the Indian media.


Remember that in the years preceding the pandemic, mainstream media in India had decided that it was better to promote the narrative set by the government rather than question it. Much of mainstream media had already set aside a basic journalistic norm – that even as you report what the government says, your job is to try and independently verify the facts and separate fact from fiction.


Also, six hours before Modi announced the lockdown, he had summoned over 20 prominent media owners and editors.  According to this report by Sagar in Caravan magazine, “The prime minister’s website reported that the journalists committed to ‘work on the suggestions of the prime minister to publish inspiring and positive stories’ about COVID-19.”


Once the lockdown was announced, the images of millions of poor people leaving cities in a panic, dragging their meagre belongings, carrying small children, helping the elderly to walk with them certainly did not constitute a “positive” story. But this was a story that even the most pro-government media simply could not ignore. And so, despite themselves, and the suggestion by the prime minister that they focus on “positive stories”, mainstream Indian media did report it.


But once the stream of displaced migrants thinned out, so did the media focus.


In fact, within days of the lockdown, mainstream media and particularly television news became obsessed with a manufactured controversy. 


Perhaps one of the most shaming episodes as far India’s mainstream media is concerned is the way it played a role in spreading Islamophobia in the early days of the outbreak of the pandemic by suggesting that the surge in Covid cases was due to a gathering in New Delhi of the Tablighi Jamaat.


As this piece in Article-14 points out, until March 29, the media focused on the exodus of migrant workers from our cities.  On that day, there was news of a spike in Covid cases.  Within three days, official statements suggested that the spike was linked to the Tablighi Jamaat gathering in New Delhi that included many followers who had travelled to India from other countries.


This was the signal that sent some sections of mainstream media into overdrive with terms like “corona bomb” and “superspreader maulana” being liberally used. 


Even if the Islamophobia eventually died down, the seeds of hate and suspicion that already existed were further nourished by this shameful media campaign. 


Although the lockdown finally ended in May 2020 after several extensions, the suffering of those who had been forced to flee certainly did not.  But their stories were not top of the news anymore as the migrants had disappeared into their villages. And mainstream media concedes some space to rural India only if there is a disaster. 


A few newspapers did report on the discrimination migrants faced when they returned to their homes as they were seen as carriers of the virus.  But after that, there was little by of follow up reports on how people survived without an income for so many months. Such stories are not dramatic like the exodus or heart-rending like the image of the child pulling at a blanket that covered his dead mother on the railway platform in Muzaffarpur. 


Unfortunately for the government, and fortunately for people, some of this information did come out, through reporting by independent news platforms.  It is here that we read stories of the events post the initial exodus.


In fact, if there is one lesson to be learnt from the coverage of the pandemic by mainstream media in 2020 and 2021 it is this: that even if they choose to ignore the reality, the real news will find its way thanks to independent media as well as social media.  


The more virulent strain of the virus that hit India in 2021 brought with it another set of challenges for the media.  For instance, this article in Scroll tells us about the telling gap between official figures of Covid deaths in Gujarat and the reality. The facts became known because some media houses did what journalists are supposed to do: Verify and double check the authenticity of official figures. Local newspapers sent reporters out to crematoria to check how many bodies were being cremated each day. The numbers were very different from the official data.


The gap between fact and fiction was even greater in Uttar Pradesh where the Yogi Adityanath government continued to claim that the situation was under control.  Yet here again, reports such as this in Newslaundry exposed the substantial discrepancy between official claims and the reality. 


This kind of coverup of actual data, especially in UP, was finally exposed when the gruesome images of shallow graves on the banks of the Ganga emerged as well as stories about overworked crematoria that could not deal with the flood of deaths.  


Among them, was Hindi newspaper Dainik Bhaskar which stood out with its front page photos of burning pyres and investigations that put a hole through official claims on death counts. Its coverage drew praise not just from other media organisations but it also won awards.


The tragic stories of poor families who had to abandon their loved ones on the banks of rivers because they could not afford the costs of cremation were a stark testimony to the deadliness of the second surge of Covid, but also of the mismanagement by governments.  There was no “positive” spin that could be given to this story. 


As for the back story that was not followed up in adequate detail by mainstream media, Supriya Sharma rightly points out in her piece in Scroll: “If the lockdown last year came down as a hammer, this year, it feels like a thousand cuts. Obscured by the dramatic and distressing images of death in the second wave of the pandemic, a slow drip of distress is going unnoticed, not just by the government, but even by other citizens, leaving the urban poor to fend for themselves.”


It is only because India has independent news platforms that we saw some reports on this “slow drip of distress”. Such stories ought to be part of routine journalism, not an exception. 


Yet over time, the space for such stories, the time and investment that is needed to investigate and write them, has virtually disappeared.  Instead, for mainstream, it is news that sells their “product” that trumps all other criteria. And how poor people survive, or rather do not, is not a selling proposition


It is now five years since the outbreak of the Covid pandemic in India.  The questions that arose then are still relevant. Have the conditions under which the millions employed in precarious and uncertain jobs, who formed part of that exodus, improved? If not, why not?

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

From Vantara to forest reserves, photo ops trump journalism

 Broken News

Published in Newslaundry on March 13, 2025

Link: https://www.newslaundry.com/2025/03/13/from-vantara-to-forest-reserves-photo-ops-trump-journalism

Compared to the Trump Tsunami that has the US president literally flooding the media with new and almost always controversial statements every day, our leaders and their politics appear almost dull. 


Even as he announced drastic job cuts in his country and the stock market went into a deep dive, Donald Trump found the time to promote his close friend and confidante Elon Musk’s electric car, Tesla, on the lawns of the White House. The concept of conflict of interest clearly does not exist in the era of Trump that we have now entered. There may be a few parallels in India.


Meanwhile, in India, the stock markets have been volatile. And there are other raging controversies, such as on the language issue and delimitation. But our prime minister seemed unperturbed as he spent a day endorsing the efforts of Anant Ambani, son of Mukesh Ambani, in setting up an animal rescue facility and what some may call a private zoo – Vantara in Jamnagar. 

Modi posed, stroking a lion who was safely ensconced in a glass cage. He was also photographed feeding tiger cubs. And all this promotional material was amplified without a question by mainstream media. There were no queries about the facility, how many animals it had, from where these animals had been brought, at what price, and whether the environment in which they were caged was suitable for them.


One newspaper did raise some questions shortly after Modi’s visit to Vantara. The Telegraph ran a story quoting a report by the Wildlife Protection Forum of South Africa (WAPFSA) which raised some uncomfortable questions about Vantara. Strangely, that story has now been taken down. And the PDF of that report as well as the statement by WAPFSA has also disappeared from its website.


But before that happened, it was mentioned in reports in Down to Earth and in Scroll, amongst other independent portals. 


The PDF of the WAPFSA report, which this columnist accessed before it disappeared, pointed out that Vantara had purchased wild animals from South Africa, some of which were endangered.  


It stated: “According to published articles, between 2019 and present day, the Radhe Krishna Temple Elephant Welfare Trust and the GZRRC have amassed what is described as an extraordinary assemblage of wildlife, including multiple endangered species. GZRRC started, according to the exact terminology of a published article, with an opening ‘stock’ of 1873 animals and during one year 2022 – 2023 acquired a further 1946 animals.” 

GZRCC stands for Greens Zoological Rescue and Rehabilitation Centre, an affiliate of Vantara.


The Down to Earth story also mentions the animals in captivity at Vantara and quotes WAPFSA: “Most wildlife experts agree that placing animals in any captive environment is itself a form of mistreatment. A life in captivity in a zoo, no matter how advanced the zoo facilities may be, can never equal a life lived in natural surroundings. Captivity enforces conditions upon wild animals in which they are not adapted to thrive.” 


Earlier in the year, Deccan Herald carried a story reporting that activists in Assam were worried about the way 21 captive elephants had been transported from Arunachal Pradesh to Jamnagar for the Vantara facility.


But these are exceptions. No questions asked or raised, no effort to get the back story. That now is the dominant norm in most of mainstream media when it comes to anything endorsed by the prime minister or the government.


For instance, after Vantara, Modi visited the 58th tiger reserve in Madhya Pradesh. An obvious question that any self-respecting media organisation should have asked is: how are the other 57 doing?


Tiger sanctuaries were enthusiastically promoted in the 1970s when Indira Gandhi was the prime minister. Project Tiger was hardly ever questioned except by a few journalists and activists. Anil Agarwal, the pioneering environmental journalist who set up the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), wrote this in “The State of India’s Environment 1982: A Citizens’ Report” about Project Tiger: “Project Tiger is a spectacular landmark in our efforts at wildlife conservation. A serious flaw in this approach, however, is highlighted by the situation in the Periyar Tiger Reserve. Here, several tribal villages were shifted out of the core zone. Dispossessed of their habitat, the tribals soon lost the little land they were given as compensation, and became pauperised. At the same time, the authorities did not remove four cardamom estates in the heart of the core zone”.


Since then, the rights of forest dwellers have found support, and the Forest Rights Act was passed in 2006. The law is not perfect but at least it recognises that forests are not just for animals but also for the people who have always lived there. However, as with so many reasonably good laws in this country, it is observed in the breach. Unless people protest, no one pays heed to such rights, particularly when the people involved are at the bottom of the economic pyramid. 


And of course, only if people come out in substantial numbers on the streets does the media pay any heed to what they are saying.


Agarwal’s observations of the Periyar Tiger Reserve are echoed even today in other tiger reserves. Take this story by The Hindu’s Odisha correspondent Satyasundar Barik on tiger sanctuaries in the state. He points out that not only were the Adivasis forced to relocate but that out of four tiger sanctuaries in the state, one has no tigers and yet vast lands have been emptied out for it.


And this story in Down to Earth points out that even today, literally thousands of Adivasis are being evicted from lands they have occupied for generations by the process of creating inviolate spaces for tigers and other wildlife.  


“These evictions are affecting nearly 400,000 Adivasis, who are now fighting to defend their homes and heritage. Protests have erupted in major tiger reserves such as Nagarhole, Kaziranga, Udanti-Sitanadi, Rajaji, and Indravati. Demonstrators are calling for an immediate halt to what they describe as illegal actions by the government.”


You will not know any of this if you only follow mainstream media. Of course, there was a time when newspapers devoted space to environmental stories, even those that made the government or corporations uncomfortable. But that is in the past. In today’s media reality, the only environment that interests the mainstream is what happens in big cities. So, air quality, and sometimes water quality, will feature as environmental stories.


Meanwhile in the rest of the country, not only are thousands of Adivasis being displaced, but rivers are being poisoned, glaciers are melting, land degradation is evident, and the mad pace of infrastructure construction everywhere is turning cities, and even small towns into dust bowls.



Tuesday, March 11, 2025

US tariffs, impact on economy: USAID row helps bury the big questions

Broken News

Published in Newslaundry on February 28, 2025

Link:  https://www.newslaundry.com/2025/02/28/us-tariffs-impact-on-economy-usaid-row-helps-bury-the-big-questions

Can the media avoid falling for the politics of distraction? Apparently not, as far as the media in India is concerned.


There is no better illustration of this than the recent controversy over an apparent US $21 million that USAID is supposed to have given to an organisation based in Washington DC to fund “voter turnout” in India.  This came up because US President Donald Trump has gone on something of a warpath against USAID, claiming it was wasting his country’s funds by giving money to countries for projects that were unsupportable.


If this was the case, then there was no story there. But the decision to cancel USAID for projects overseas took a turn in India that could have been considered funny if it wasn’t so pathetic.


Within days of Trump’s announcement about cancelling the $21 million for India, the blame game was in full swing. The BJP’s Information and Technology Cell head Amit Malviya called the Congress party “desperate” and accused it of routing the USAID fund through “various George Soros-linked fronts and a labyrinth of NGO structures to meddle with India’s electoral process”. Congress spokesperson Jairam Ramesh responded by pointing out that “USAID is currently implementing seven projects in collaboration with the government of India, with a combined budget of approximately $750 million. Not a single of these projects has to do with voter turnout. All of them are with and through the Union government.”


To add masala to this “unhinged public discourse”, as The Hindu termed it in its editorial, the originator of the controversy, Donald Trump himself, added to the confusion by first reiterating that the funds had been given because “I guess they were trying to get somebody else elected.” And then claiming the funds were going “to my friend Prime Minister Modi in India for voter turnout”, and then arbitrarily reducing the amount from $21 million to $18 million.


Meanwhile, the Indian media, especially television news that loves a good controversy, parroted all this without as much as a raised eyebrow. 


Fortunately, we still have some print media organisations that do what any journalistic endeavour should do: investigate and find out facts.


The Indian Express led with a front-page story that established that the magical figure of $21 million was the exact same as what USAID had given to organisations in Bangladesh in the run-up to the 2024 general elections. And the USAID website had no record of a similar amount going to India. So, did Trump get mixed up between Dhaka and Delhi? Or was this part of a deliberate strategy to stir up a controversy?


The controversy ought to have been settled after the Indian Express story. Subsequently more “facts”, rather than rhetoric, appeared in the print media when official government documents established that in the last four years, the government has received $650 million for a variety of projects as outlined by the fact-check site Boom. And that over the years, irrespective of the government in power, USAID has been funding official government projects in India – including healthcare, education and sanitation – as illustrated by this graphic in Times of India. 

imageby :Times of India

In addition to this, it is entirely possible that some non-governmental organisations received funds from foundations or non-profits in the US that were partly funded by USAID.  Even if some did, we still need to establish if any of them were even remotely involved in something as political as enhancing “voter turnout”. Given that the Modi government has cancelled the FCRA (Foreign Contributions Regulation Act) licenses of thousands of NGOs, it is unlikely that any of those considered even remotely political would have survived the axe.


Apart from finding out the facts and reporting them, rather than routinely repeating accusations by politicians on both sides, what really needs to be investigated is why the BJP trumped this up as a major controversy for which predictably, both the opposition and mainstream media fell. And who gains from it.


This politics of distraction is now a well-known ploy. As Ravish Kumar points out in one of his recent programmes, while we were discussing many non-issues, the country’s stock markets were falling and no one was asking the government why this was happening. While the governments of Assam and Madhya Pradesh were hosting “global” investment meetings, there was hardly any discussion about the consequences of Trump’s threat that he would charge India the same tariffs as India charged for US imports. How would this affect the Indian economy and foreign investment? Did the Modi government have a strategy to handle the consequences of raised tariffs? These questions were left hanging in the air.


And as suddenly as it popped up, the USAID controversy has disappeared. The government has not confirmed or denied this mythical sum of $21 million for “voter turnout” despite making statements that it was concerned and was looking into it. And the Indian media has dropped the subject. 


Also, now that the Maha Kumbh has ended, even the controversy about the quality of the water in the Ganges in which millions of people took a dip, generated by the report of the Central Pollution Control Board, will not be discussed anymore even though the state of India’s rivers ought to be an urgent concern for everyone, irrespective of their religious significance.


To end, I leave you with this article by Shailendra Yashwant in Deccan Herald on the state of the Yamuna, one of the three rivers that form part of the Sangam in Prayagraj. It reminds us of the crisis our rivers face as they continue to be blocked by dams and barrages, slowing down their natural flow, and then treated as sewers along the way by every town and city on their banks until their waters are not only unfit for drinking but even for bathing.